The Electronic Journal of Business Research Methods provides perspectives on topics relevant to research in the field of business and management
Click here to see other Scholarly Electronic Journals published by API
For a range of research text books on this and complimentary topics visit the Academic Bookshop
Information about The European Conference on Research Methodology for Business and Management Studies is available here

linkedin-120 

 

twitter2-125 

 

fb_logo-125 

 
Journal Issue
Volume 10 Issue 2, ECRM / Dec 2012  pp53‑153

Editor: Ann Brown

Download PDF (free)

Editorial for the ECRM 2012 Special Issue of EJBRM  pp53‑53

Ann Brown

Look inside Download PDF (free)

Integrating Sustainable Development into Research Ethics Protocols  pp54‑63

Anthony Stacey, Julie Stacey

Look inside Download PDF (free)

A Multi‑Methodological Framework for the Design and Evaluation of Complex Research Projects and Reports in Business and Management Studies  pp64‑76

Hendrik Marais

Look inside Download PDF (free)

Looking at the Past to Enrich the Future: A Reflection on Klein and Myers’ Quality Criteria for Interpretive Research  pp77‑88

Ana Cardoso, Isabel Ramos

Look inside Download PDF (free)

Abstract

In the last two decades, interpretive research has become more established and more popular in information systems field. The work of Klein and Myers (1999) consists of a set of principles for conducting and evaluating interpretive research, which provide fair and appropriate criteria for assessing the validity and reliability of such studies and, given the number of citations, has had a significant impact in the interpretive research literature. Our article focuses on understanding how this set of principles has informed research articles published in two of the highest‑ranked information systems journals and, specifically, questions if these principles have been translated into common practices when conducting interpretive research in the field of information systems and whether authors incorporate them explicitly when they communicate the results of their research. We reviewed articles published in Management Information Systems Quarterly and Information Systems Research, collected any explicit or implicit evidence of quality criteria that informed the research, and highlighted direct or indirect reference to Klein and Myers criteria. We summarize and compare our findings in a comprehensive table, and note that, apparently, the principle of hermeneutic circle and the principle of suspicion are the most explicitly discussed in this sample. Moreover, Klein and Myers’ set of principles seem to have had a greater influence in the papers published in the period from 2002 to 2006. This study provides a reflexion about methodological rigor in interpretive research that, to our knowledge, had never been done. Thus, the findings here presented may be useful for junior researchers and doctorate level students to understand how validity and quality criteria are enacted in high‑quality interpretive research and, we hope, may encourage them to build on the exemplary work of the authors we reviewed and thus to contribute to enriching the literature of qualitative research methodology in information systems field. 

 

Keywords: interpretive research evaluation, quality and rigor criteria, information systems, Klein & Myers’ set of principles, hermeneutics, phenomenology.

 

Share |
A Proposal and Evaluation of a Design Method in Design Science Research  pp89‑100

Francis Gacenga, Aileen Cater-Steel, Mark Toleman, Wui-Gee Tan

Look inside Download PDF (free)

A Technical Guide to Effective and Accessible Web Surveys  pp101‑109

Greg Baatard

Look inside Download PDF (free)

Generating a new Interview Method by using Sensing Technology to Assess Human Emotions  pp110‑120

Yayoi Hirose, Kiyoshi Itao, Tomohiro Umeda

Look inside Download PDF (free)

The Educational Scorecard: The Start of our Journey  pp121‑131

Vivienne Griggs, Michelle Blackburn, Joanna Smith

Look inside Download PDF (free)

Research Philosophy Debates and Classifications: Students’ Dilemma  pp132‑140

Marcia Mkansi, Edwin Asiamah Acheampong

Look inside Download PDF (free)

Eating our own Cooking: Toward a More Rigorous Design Science of Research Methods  pp141‑153

John Venable, Richard Baskerville

Look inside Download PDF (free)